80-20+ logo80-20+
← Back to Issues
Education

Catholic Schools Outscore Public Schools. Graduation Is the Bigger Gap.

Catholic schools' test-score lead partly reflects who enrolls; the bigger difference they make for a child is whether he or she finishes high school.

4 min
Key takeaways
  • →Catholic school students have outscored public school students on the federal long-term national test at every age since the late 1970s. Score differentials increase with a student's age. In 2025, Catholic 13-year-olds led by 22 points in math.
  • →Test scores reflect the families who choose a school as well as the school itself. Comparing students from similar backgrounds erased more than half of the Catholic lead.
  • →The difference that holds up best is graduation: attending a Catholic high school raised a student's chance of finishing by 8 to 9 percentage points, and by 19 for urban minority students.
  • →In a Washington, D.C., program that pays private school tuition for low-income families, test scores didn't change, but fewer students regularly missed school and more parents called the school very safe.
  • →What families are choosing is a package: clear expectations of students, faculty, and staff, a safer environment, higher graduation and college entry rates, and other growth opportunities like duty to others.
Photo: Canva

For parents choosing between the neighborhood public school and a Catholic one, the comparison usually starts with test scores. On that measure, Catholic schools make an easy case. The focus is on Catholic schools among many private school options, as they are the most broadly studied.

In 2025, Catholic school 13-year-olds outscored public school 13-year-olds by 22 points in math on the federal government's long-term national test. Catholic students have led on that test at every age since the late 1970s, and the gap has never closed.

Average math scores of 13-year-olds, public vs. Catholic schools, 1978–2025

scale points

Source: National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress, Long-Term Trend assessment, 2025 technical and results appendix

View the data
YearPublicCatholic
1978263279
1990269279
1999274288
2012284295
2020279293
2025269291

But a school's test scores can say as much about the students it enrolls as about how well it teaches them. When researchers compare Catholic and public school students from similar families, the clearest difference shows up in whether a child finishes high school. Research on private schools more broadly finds the same pattern in whether children come to school and feel safe there.

Test scores are harder to judge than they look, because part of what goes into them comes from home. A federal analysis compared Catholic and public school students from similar backgrounds, accounting for family income, parents' education, and a few other factors. More than half of the Catholic lead disappeared. A Catholic lead held up in eighth-grade reading, while public schools came out ahead in fourth-grade math.

Catholic school lead over public schools, before and after adjusting for student background

scale points

Source: National Center for Education Statistics, Comparing Private Schools and Public Schools Using Hierarchical Linear Modeling (NCES 2006-461)

View the data
Grade and subjectRaw leadLead after adjusting
Grade 4 reading16.11.5
Grade 4 math8.2-4.3
Grade 8 reading19.38.0
Grade 8 math120

How much Catholic schools themselves add to test scores is still unsettled, because the scores can't separate what the school did from what the family did. That leaves a parent's real question unanswered: What will this school do for my child?

The answer to that question is that families that choose Catholic schools are deciding on more than just educational benefits; they are buying a package: clear expectations of students, faculty and staff, a safer environment, higher graduation and college entry rates, and other benefits. However, as with any class of schools, not all Catholic schools are equal.

Graduation rate is a clear Catholic school advantage. A 2005 study, designed to separate a school's effect from its families, found that attending a Catholic high school raised a student's chance of graduating by 8 to 9 percentage points. In a class of 100, that's 8 or 9 more teenagers who finish. For urban minority students, the gain was 19 points.

Yet the same study found that Catholic high school students did only slightly better on math tests than public school students with similar backgrounds and families.

The strongest objection to the conclusion that Catholic schools have better graduation rates is that family differences explain that too, and the study tested this directly. For hidden family differences to account for the result, they would need to be more than three and a half times as strong as all the differences the researchers did measure. The study authors judged that highly unlikely.

Attendance and safety show the same pattern. Washington, D.C., runs a federally funded program that pays private school tuition for children from low-income families. Three years in, the children offered that help scored no better in reading or math, but fewer of them regularly missed school; about one in five, compared with more than one in four of the children not in the program.

Parents noticed a difference too. Among families offered the tuition help, 72.2 percent called their child's school very safe, compared with 55.6 percent of families who applied and didn't get it. These were private schools of all kinds, not only Catholic ones, and the children in them came to school more and felt safer even though their scores stayed flat.

Much of what Catholic schools offer is a clear set of expectations. In the last federal survey to ask, most Catholic schools required community service; few public schools did. A family that picks one is signing up for expectations about behavior, homework and duty to others, and for a school where the adults and the other students take them seriously.

Research on charter schools suggests expectations like these count for more than time or money, even on test scores. In a study of charter schools that admit students by lottery, how strictly a school enforced its rules for behavior predicted math gains worth roughly a year of learning. More class time and higher spending per student predicted nothing.

Parents, not the state, are a child's primary educators, and the choice of school belongs to them. The evidence suggests looking past just the test-score table when making it.

When visiting a school, ask how many of its students graduate, since that is where the clearest difference shows. Find out how many students regularly miss school and whether students and parents say they feel safe. And ask what the school expects of students, and who holds them to it.

A school's test scores say a lot about the families who already send their children there. The bigger question for a parent is whether their own child will be there on graduation day.

Principle at stake

Parents, not the state, are a child's first educators, and the choice of a school belongs to them. To make it well, they need to know what a school does for a child: expectations in academics and behavior, whether the child graduates, comes to school, and feels safe. That is where the evidence shows the clearest differences, and it is information any parent can ask a school for.

Facts & figures
  • 22 points: Catholic 13-year-olds' lead over public school 13-year-olds in math on the federal long-term national test in 2025.
  • More than half: the share of the Catholic lead that disappeared when a federal analysis of the 2003 test compared students from similar backgrounds.
  • 8 to 9 percentage points: the increase in the chance of graduating from attending a Catholic high school; 19 points for urban minority students.
  • 20% fewer students regularly missing school in Washington, D.C.'s tuition program for low-income families (21.9% of those offered tuition help vs. 27.3% of those who weren't; private schools generally).
  • 30% increase in parents in D.C.'s program who called their child's school very safe (families offered tuition help vs. those who weren't).
Key talking points
  • →Catholic school students have outscored public school students on the federal long-term national test at every age since the late 1970s.
  • →A school's test scores can reflect who enrolls as much as what the school does; the clearest difference a Catholic high school makes is graduation rate, 8 to 9 percentage points higher.
  • →In a D.C. program that pays private school tuition for low-income families, test scores didn't change, but fewer students regularly missed school and more parents called the school very safe.
  • →What families choose in a Catholic school is a set of expectations about behavior, homework, and duty to others.
  • →When comparing schools, ask how many students graduate, how many regularly miss school, and whether students feel safe.

Related issues

Stay informed

Plain-language explainers and sourced updates, in your inbox. No spin, unsubscribe anytime.